IRRITABLE BOWEL SYNDROME
Aka the Western diet
Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS) refers to vague, chronic gastrointestinal problems without an identifiable cause. Patients typically complain of abdominal pain plus diarrhea and / or constipation. Their symptoms are typically mild, persistent, frustrating and annoying.
The diagnostic criteria for IBS are laughably vague (the Rome criteria), but I bring it up because one of them frequently appears on vignettes. Their abdominal pain changes when they poop; either getting better or worse. This will usually be your clue in a question stem.
IBS is a little controversial, because science can’t explain it. Having worked at a GI clinic for a year, I’ve seen plenty of patients diagnosed with IBS. Most of them were overweight middle-aged adults with poor diets and sedentary lifestyles. The gastroenterologist would do a colonoscopy, because that's what gastroenterologists do. The colonoscopy would be normal. So the doctor would throw his hands up and say “Well shoot! I guess you have IBS.” It’s a diagnosis of exclusion. The treatment is aimed at minimizing symptoms rather than treating an underlying cause. Unfortunately, treatment rarely works (only 20% achieve symptom remission).
Let’s talk about the treatment algorithm. The first step is to lose weight, exercise and adopt the FODMAP diet (which is low in gas-producing foods). RCTs on exercise are difficult to conduct, but working out seems to be the most promising treatment. Next, patients are told to take fiber, although this is rarely effective. Now there is a fork in the pathway, and we’re either going to focus on treating the constipation or the diarrhea. For constipation, we start with polyethylene glycol (osmotic), then we try Lubiprostone (secretory) then Tegaserod (serotonin agonist). For diarrhea, treatment mainly consists of Loperamide, although a few patients benefit from bile acid sequestrants. One of the most surprising developments in IBS was the discovery that some patients improved with antidepressants like a TCA or SSRI. It’s still too early to say if probiotics are helpful.
Call me a skeptic, but I don’t believe that a disease called IBS exists. Rather, I think it’s an umbrella diagnosis that encompasses a wide variety of intestinal problems. There is no clear scientific consensus on the true cause, but instead a heterogenous mixture of explanations. Some retrospective studies have found that most patients initially diagnosed with IBS were later found to have a “real” cause, one which responded well to treatment. There are no biomarkers. There are no lesions on endoscopy. There’s no reliable testing. From my experience working at a GI clinic, I observed that encounters with IBS patients were frustrating for both the doctor and the patient.
REMINDER
IBS is very, very different from IBD.